07 May 2010

Did Warrantless Eavesdropping Catch the Time Square Bomber?

George Smiley speculates, from a professional perspective, on how the Times Square bomber was so rapidly apprehended.

Remember how angry the left used to be about Bush Administration warrantless eavesdropping? There is a pretty strong likelihood that something very much of the kind may have recently occurred.

Shortly after Times Square bombing suspect Faisal Shahzad was apprehended, various accounts began to circulate about how the authorities managed to track him down. One of the most intriguing appeared on the WCBS-TV website (and has since been removed). It suggested that intelligence assets were involved in tracing Shahzad’s cell phone conversations. We instantly regretted not saving a copy of the story, but The Talkmaster saw the same item, and offered this summary:

They knew he had one of those throw-away cell phones, and they knew the number. It was the number he used to call the lady who sold him the SUV. So, as I understand it, our intelligence people had some “assets” in the air over New York City that were intercepting cell phone calls and sifting through them looking for this one number. Finally they caught this guy making a phone call to the reservations number for Emirates Airlines. Like I said, pretty scary, and impressive.

If we recall correctly, WCBS originally reported that “Army” intelligence aircraft were used in tracking the suspect’s cell phone conversations. If that’s the case (and no one has actually confirmed the original report by Channel 2), the most likely candidate is the RC-12 Guardrail, a Corps-level Army SIGINT asset that collects communications and electronic intelligence. Operating in groups of three, Guardrail aircraft can collect over a wide area and transmit their “haul” to ground collection stations. …

[Thereafter, who knows? certain ground signals platforms might have] beam[ed] their collection directly to the National Security Agency for further analysis and dissemination. .. If you’re looking for a single cell phone–in a sea of millions–it’s quite helpful to have NSA and its massive collection and identification capabilities on your side.

Still, using an organization like NSA to assist in the hunt for a terrorist (who happens to be an American citizen and is inside our borders to boot) puts the government on shaky legal ground. In most operations of this type, the Justice Department would have to go to the FISA court for a warrant, authorizing electronic surveillance for Mr. Shahzad. But, as we’ve learned in recent years, it sometimes takes two or three weeks to obtain that type of warrant–too slow to nab a suspected terrorist who may be trying to flee the country.

How would the feds overcome that legal obstacle? This is pure conjecture on our part, but in this type of scenario, something called Echelon would be quite useful. To be sure, the existence of the program (an information collection and sharing agreement between NSA and its British, Canadian and Australian partners) has been widely debated. Officially, NSA has refused to confirm that the program was established and remains operational.

So, for argument’s sake, let’s say the program exists, and provides significant collection and analysis for the western SIGINT agencies. We’ll also speculate that this arrangement is largely transparent, with data being collected and exchanged almost instantaneously. With those capabilities in place, it would be possible for Britain’s GCHQ (their version of NSA) to run collection against Faisal Shahzad, then tip U.S. authorities when he made that call to Emirates Air. That would give the feds actionable intelligence, allowing them to converge on JFK Airport, and remove the suspect from the Dubai-bound flight.

We should also mention that the “seamless” relationship allows organizations like GCHQ to receive and analyze information collected from U.S. platforms, like the RC-135. While the raw data was gathered by an American aircraft, the analysis is done by British specialists, who can then pass it on to their U.S. counterparts. It may sound like an unnecessary “extra” step, but if you’re under enormous pressure to find an American suspect on U.S. soil–and you don’t have the time to dot every “i” and cross every “t” in FISA court, this arrangement can provide an effective work-around? …

[The original surveillance by airplane report was from] WCBS-TV. Either the story was completely off-base (a distinct possibility), or a federal official spoke a little too freely and the station was asked to spike the story. Additionally, we later managed to find a copy of the station’s original report at the left-wing website FireDogLake:

Shahzad, 30, a Pakistan-born U.S. citizen, has been in custody since shortly after midnight. He was hauled off a plane in the nick of time as it was about to fly to the Middle East. CBS 2 obtained air traffic control recording intended to stop the pilots from taking off. The controller alerts pilots to “immediately” return to the gate.

    In the end, it was secret Army intelligence planes that did him in. Armed with his cell phone number, they circled the skies over the New York area, intercepting a call to Emirates Airlines reservations, before scrambling to catch him at John F. Kennedy International Airport.

We don’t often agree with the folks at FireDogLake, but they got it right in noting that the original WCBS report raises some rather interesting questions. We won’t hold our breath waiting for answers.

We probably won’t be seeing cartoons like this one, though.


Please Leave a Comment!

Please note: Comments may be moderated. It may take a while for them to show on the page.


Entries (RSS)
Comments (RSS)
Feed Shark