10 Feb 2018

L.L. Bean Drops Life-Time Guarantee

, ,

L.L. Bean has a more fashionable and up-to-date customer base these days, and they are consequently dropping their famous “No Questions Asked — Lifetime Warranty” policy. NPR reports:

L.L. Bean’s outdoor gear — including its signature Bean Boots prized by campers and hipsters alike — is no longer guaranteed for life.

In a letter to customers Friday morning, the company said it has updated its return policy to give customers one year to return purchases, with a receipt. The previous lifetime guarantee, which enabled customers to return products years — or even decades — after purchase, has long been a selling point for the company.

[Emphasis added]

“Increasingly, a small, but growing number of customers has been interpreting our guarantee well beyond its original intent. Some view it as a lifetime product replacement program, expecting refunds for heavily worn products used over many years. Others seek refunds for products that have been purchased through third parties, such as at yard sales.”‘

L.L. Bean says the policy update will affect only a “small percentage” of returns and pledged to keep its mission of selling “high quality products that inspire and enable people to enjoy the outdoors.” The company says if a product is defective, it will “work with our customers to reach a fair solution” even after a year.

The return policy on the site now reads:

    “If you are not 100% satisfied with one of our products, you may return it within one year of purchase for a refund. After one year, we will consider any items for return that are defective due to materials or craftsmanship.”

A Business Insider reporter put the policy to the test last year by returning four-year-old shoes with broken stitching. He recounts that the cashier immediately accepted the return and asked for no proof about when he purchased the shoes. “Two days later, the brand-new shoes were waiting on my doorstep,” Business Insider writes.

At the time, an L.L. Bean spokesperson told the site that the return policy was taken advantage of less than might be expected.

“Our guarantee is not a liability, but rather a customer service asset — an unacknowledged agreement between us and the customer, that always puts the customer first and relies on the goodwill of our customers to honor the original intent of the guarantee,” spokesperson Mac McKeever told Business Insider.

The company traces its origins to 1911, when a Maine outdoorsman developed a hunting shoe with leather uppers and rubber bottoms. Its rugged products were designed with hunting and fishing in mind.

In recent years the company has taken steps to appeal to a hipper, less outdoorsy clientele. As Maine Public Radio reported, L.L. Bean has been “looking to really create a new updated fit and style.”

In the old days, L.L. Bean used to sell to real Americans, hunters and fishermen. In my family, we always wore Pennsylvania-made Woolrich coats in deer season, but we preferred the fit, features, and durability of Bean’s canvas hunting coat for Upland Game season. Maine was far away, and Bean’s hunting coats were expensive, but you only ever needed to buy one once. That hunting coat would last your lifetime.

Now, in the old days, nobody in the former customer base would have thought of ripping off L.L. Bean by going out and buying a shot-down pair of 50-year-old Maine Hunting Shoes at a yard sale and then invoking the life-time guarantee.

But, when you go out there and start trading with the hipsters and the liberal fashionistas from the city, the kind of people who shop at Patagonia and the revived gender-ambiguous “Abercrombie & Fitch,” well, it just ain’t the way it used to be anymore. Those new customers are not your friends and neighbors.

6 Feedbacks on "L.L. Bean Drops Life-Time Guarantee"


I can accept that the world changes but I’ll never be convinced it’s all for the better.

Dick the Butcher

I greatly appreciate my Maine Hunting Boots. However, ! only wear them in the woods or shoveling deep snow. The soles will quickly wear out on sidewalks or pavement.

Seattle Sam

Not a smart move on LL Bean’s part. The number of people who abuse the policy cannot represent a greater cost than what the guarantee contributes to their brand idea. This is what happens when the bean-counters take over a company from the marketers.

Capt. Craig

You are wrong Sam. I saw this coming years ago when a “friend” bought a pair of shorts at a yard sale and said he always looks for L.L, Bean so he can return the item for a new one. I am sure that they have been taking heavy losses and finally have had enough.


I witnessed a construction worker return about 10 pair of Roebucks jeans that looked like Alan Jackson wore them to Sears with no questions asked for 10 new pair. Flabbergasted!!!


I used to work for L L Bean and I agree that they had to change their policy because the world has changed. Their guarantee used to be: we guarantee our product for the expected life of the product..if a pair of boots didn’t perform as you’d expect it to perform or …any other product for that matter, we will replace it. The consumer mistook this to mean that a product had to last them for their whole life, and that any product could be returned for any reason. If you worked for L L Bean and had to deal with people returning old, worn out, and used products for full retail value over and over, you would understand why they had to change their policy. It’s really unfortunate. In today’s world, there are just too many people who will take advantage of a good faith policy, and try to graft the system.


Please Leave a Comment!

Please note: Comments may be moderated. It may take a while for them to show on the page.

Entries (RSS)
Comments (RSS)
Feed Shark