WASHINGTON, D.C.â€”At a campaign rally designed to drum up enthusiasm among Democratic voters, failed presidential candidate Hillary Clinton took the stage in an ominous black cloak and began encouraging her audience to let their anger control them.
“Yes, good, good,” she said, nodding at the crowd’s visible angst as an evil smile crept across her face. “The hate is swelling in you now. Take up weapons against Republicansâ€” use them. Strike me down if you have to. Give in to your anger. With each passing moment, you make yourselves more my servants!”
She then threw back her cloak and cackled at the sky, hands blasting powerful electric charges at several of her aides, who were fried to a crisp. “Use your aggressive feelings, Democrats. Let the hate flow through you!”
Several assistants rushed the stage, pleading with her to find “the light” within her: “Your overconfidence is your weakness, Hillary!”
But she laughed off this assault, electrocuting those who would have tried to turn her in a split second. “And your faith in the outdated notion of civility is yours!”
Hillary Clinton rejected calls for a return to civility in American politics during an interview on Tuesday, arguing instead that civility can only return once Democrats take back control of Congress.
â€œYou cannot be civil with a political party that wants to destroy what you stand for, what you care about,â€ Clinton told CNNâ€™s Christiane Amanpour. â€œThatâ€™s why I believe, if we are fortunate enough to win back the House and or the Senate, thatâ€™s when civility can start again. But until then, the only thing that the Republicans seem to recognize and respect is strength.â€
James Taranto, in the Wall Street Journal, explains where all the incivility is coming from.
“Terrorist,” “racist,” “uncivil,” “insane,” the list goes on–in this context, these words have no real meaning. They are mere epithets. The Obama presidency has reduced the liberal left to an apoplectic rage. His Ivy League credentials, superior attitude, pseudointellectual mien and facile adherence to lefty ideology make him the perfect personification of the liberal elite. Thus far at least, he has been an utter failure both at winning public support and at managing the affairs of the nation.
Obama’s failure is the failure of the liberal elite, and that is why their ressentiment has reached such intensity. Their ideas, such as they are, are being put to a real-world test and found severely wanting. As a result, their authority is collapsing. And if there is one thing they know deep in their bones, it is that they are entitled to that authority. They lash out, desperately and pathetically, because they have nothing to offer but fear and anger.
Civility, Colleges and Universities, Colleges and Universities, Davidson College, Diversity, Hypocrisy, University of Iowa
Civility and a non-hostile atmosphere are crucial, we have recently been advised by various representatives of the left, for young feminists to be able to participate equally in academic programs at major universities like Yale.
Does that mean that young conservatives are also entitled to civility? A couple of recent incidents of expression of hostility by left-wing faculty members raised the issue of equal civility toward conservatives, according to Jay Schalin of the Pope Center for Higher Education Policy.
[A] campus-wide email recruiting campaign by the University of Iowa College Republicans called “Conservative Coming Out Week” so enraged one professor that she responded with a mass email of her own saying â€œF— You Republicans.â€
The other incident occurred at Davidson College, a small, prestigious private school outside of Charlotte, North Carolina. This time it was a professorâ€™s abusive letter to the editor of the student newspaper attacking a conservative student columnist. While it did not receive anywhere near the national attention that the Iowa episode didâ€”possibly because no profanity was involvedâ€”it perhaps caused more of a stir on its own campus than did the Iowa episode.
The roots of this phenomenon most likely lie in the political imbalance on many campuses, which results in an atmosphere allowing left-wing professors to avoid criticism of even their most extreme views. Dissenting opinions, particularly by students fearful of lowered grades and ostracism, were once uncommon on campuses. But today there is a growingâ€”and increasingly vocalâ€”conservative student presence.
For the two professors involved, it appears that having their sacred political cows gored by swaggeringly aggressive conservatives on the hallowed ground of the Ivory Tower was too much to bear, and they erupted with a torrent of angry words.
The Iowa case readily illustrates these dynamics. Ellen Lewin, a womenâ€™s studies and anthropology professor who specializes in gender issues, claimed that the main reason for her fury was the College Republicanâ€™s expropriation of the term â€œcoming out.â€ The Republicansâ€™ wordplay was an obvious attempt to draw a parallel between the tendency of campus conservatives to hide their opinions from professors and fellow students and the tendency of many gays to remain in the â€œcloset,â€ in both cases for fear of facing discrimination and hostility. …
At Davidson, German professor Scott Denhamâ€™s fuse burnt more slowly than did Lewinâ€™s, but he exploded much the same. For four years, senior Bobby DesPain was a political columnist for the student newspaper, The Davidsonian. His opinions were unabashedly conservative and often unpopular on the highly liberal campus. On March 31, his column claiming that President Obama lacked leadership appeared; it was the final straw for Denham, who fired off a letter that began by asking, â€œIs Bobby DesPain leaving soon? We, your loyal readers, sure hope so. He gives the intellectual climate here a bad reputation.â€
He continued, â€œThis last belch of his tops most of the others Iâ€™ve read over the years on the stench-o-meter of silliness. â€œ He concluded the largely ad hominem assault with â€œWeâ€™d hate for Davidson to attract more of this sort of illogical thinker, regardless of politics.â€ …
The Davidson administration has declined to make any statement regarding the situation. At Iowa, university president Sally Mason issued a bland general statement about diversity and respect that avoided any specific mention of the incident.
Nor has either professor has received any sort of punishmentâ€”at least publicly. Both issued apologies that were notable for their absence of contrition. At Iowa, Lewinâ€™s blamed â€œfresh outrages committed by Republicans in the governmentâ€ for her profane missive.
Denham continued to attack even in his apology, blaming his â€œfrustration and anger in public at what I find are poorly argued ideas on your part. Engaging those in detail wasnâ€™t on my agenda, since I donâ€™t think there is much to engage.â€ …
Davidson philosophy professor Sean McKeever asked in a letter to The Davidsonian whether Denhamâ€™s â€œcontemptâ€ for DesPain â€œcan be consistent with our chosen vocation as educators or with the Collegeâ€™s mission to develop humane instincts.â€
Indeed, by reacting to studentsâ€™ differing opinions with such unprofessional and acrimonious emotional outbursts, one must wonder about the offending professorsâ€™ fitness for their jobs and what kind of judgment they will use in campus business such as grading and serving on search, tenure, and promotion committees.
For instance, Denham is the committee chair for the Graduate Fellowships Committee. Since, according to the committeeâ€™s website, the committee â€œseeks to identify early in their Davidson careers students who are likely candidates for graduate fellowships and scholarships,â€ can he be expected to recruit conservative students for such honors? It would appear to be unlikely.
Given that conservative beliefs on campus seem to be on the ascendance, and given that some of Americaâ€™s most extreme intellectuals have long found a sanctuary in the Ivory Tower (and have grown comfortable with winning one-sided debates), we can probably expect to see more incidents like those at Iowa and Davidson.
Union demonstrators chanting “Shame! Shame!” (rather hyperbolically and monotonously, I thought), and eventually “You Suck!”, hounded and ultimately trapped GOP State Senator Glenn Grothman near the doors of one of the entrances to the Badger State’s Capitol. (around 2:50)
It was beginning to look like the mob was close to attacking the white-haired state senator, when Democratic Rep. Brett Hulsey (wearing orange pro-union t-shirt) interposed himself between Grothman and the mob and managed to hold them off, as alarmed demonstration leaders in the rear hastily changed the chanting to “Peace-ful, Peace-ful.”
Remember Congressman Mike Capuano’s (D-8thMA) February 22nd statement that “Every once and awhile you need to get out on the streets and get a little bloody when necessary.â€?
Capuano’s rhetorical call to spill blood in the cause of Unionism (later retracted and apologized for, after the comment received national attention) might very easily have been responded to in reality yesterday. Republican legislators had better take to approaching the capitol with bodyguards or police escorts.
National Journalâ€™s Michael Hirsh wants to raise the bar on metaphorical speech to an entirely new level.
Charles Krauthammer comments on liberal hypocrisy, noting just how uncivil the left was in the case of George W. Bush.
NYM is a polite blog, and foul language is not acceptable in comments posted here.
Jake DeSantis’s letter of resignation provoked an extraordinary outpouring of opinion on both sides, and I actually took the trouble to **** out the worst examples and keep the comments otherwise intact. My normal policy is simply to delete any comments that feature foul language, and in future I’m returning to that policy.
Comments are welcome and appreciated, but readers ought to realize that they are writing formally and for a record potentially read by large numbers of people of mixed age and gender.